Download in
Google Play
17
Share
Save
Sign up
Access to all documents
Join milions of students
Improve your grades
By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Sign up
Access to all documents
Join milions of students
Improve your grades
By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Sign up
Access to all documents
Join milions of students
Improve your grades
By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
Sign up
Access to all documents
Join milions of students
Improve your grades
By signing up you accept Terms of Service and Privacy Policy
68 Idiographic vs nomothetic approach ● Idiographic - approach to research that focuses on the individual case to understand behaviour • nomothetic approach to research that to study human behaviour through the development of general principles Idiographic • focus - uniqueness. We should be looking at people individually and not attempt to make comparisons to norms • types of experiment used - case studies, unstructured interviews, other self report methods Type of data collected - Qualitative to gain rich and insightful description of human experience subjective - individual and personal experience, motivation and values, hard to replicate Idiographic vs nomothetic approach 1 • Outcomes - understanding - not concerned with general laws or comparing with large groups • case studies - Clive wearing, Gage, Genie, little Hans approaches - Psychodynamic (different experiences of psychosexual stages), humanistic (hierarchy of needs - different experience of each level) ● Nomothetic • focus - generalisations- understanding behaviour on a wider scale and looking at large numbers of people to apply a behaviour to the population • Type of experiment used - scientific methods - where hypotheses can be formulated and tested under controlled conditions ● Type of data collected - quantitative - to gain more data and make easier comparisons across groups • Scientific - objective - employs scientific methods and obtains quantitative data - harder to make interpretations from • Outcomes - prediction - concerned with comparing...
iOS User
Stefan S, iOS User
SuSSan, iOS User
large groups and being able to make predictions about future behaviour to control it ● approaches - behaviourist (findings are applied to all and uses lab experiments), cognitive (cognitive neuroscience), biological (uses objective methods, GWAS), social learning theory (uses lab experiments) • key studies - Strange situation, Asch's line study, Milgram's obedience experiment, Adorno Hazan and Shaver idiographic approaches are more likely to give a complete account of behaviour because it uses qualitative methods to provide in depth and global descriptions of individual cases o Cannot generalise and make general laws without further research o means that we do not have complete theories for all human behaviour, only small cases Idiographic vs nomothetic approach 2 o Idiographic approaches can reveal important information about single cases to generate hypotheses about wider population behaviour and then nomothetic research can be conducted ▪ Example: Clive wearing as a case study - Tulving(1997) who did a brain scan to back up these findings on LTM o Nomothetic approaches have greater scientific credibility - makes studies more objective and replicable which increases validity o Nomothetic approaches look at big samples and generalisation which means we lose a person's experience Study ■ For example, we know that there is a 1% lifetime risk in the general population for developing schizophrenia - this doesn't tell us the subjective experience of what it is like to live with schizophrenia Koluchova - Twin boys were locked in a cupboard from 18m to 7y. After they were found they lived in a loving family and they recovered fully. This showed that there may not be a critical period for psychological damage and any damage can be overcome Using SSRIs to treat depression - these antidepressant drugs prevent the reabsorption and breakdown of serotonin so there is an increase in the level of serotonin at the synapse Idiographic vs nomothetic approach I or N? Idiographic Nomothetic Justification Because it is a case study and qualitative data is collected and the findings are used to draw the conclusion that there may not be a critical period which is applied to the greater population Uses lab experiments and brain scans to find this out 3 Study Gardner and Gardner - Attempted to teach a chimp to use sign language. Over 32 months detailed records were kept of the progress where 30 signs could be made in 2 way conversations. This showed that a chimpanzee does have the capability to use human language Eysenck's personality theory: personality can be broken down into two different dimensions: neuroticism-stability and introversion-extraversion. Everyone varies in the extent to which we are introvert or extravert or neurotic. These are measured by a personality questionnaire. Idiographic vs Nomothetic - evaluation Idiographic vs nomothetic approach I or N? Idiographic Nomothetic Justification collects qualitative data and only studies one chimp and findings are generalised Collects a range of data from different people 4
revision notes for issues and debates
100
Notes on the whole issues and debates topic - AQA A level psychology
92
Use these points to easily compare approaches in paper 2. Also the acronym DRIVEN will make sure you include every point to achieve full marks
15
Psychology AQA - issues and debates - nomothetic vs idiographic - AO1/AO3
3
A level psychology
17
16 marker model essay answer
14
AQA A Level
68 Idiographic vs nomothetic approach ● Idiographic - approach to research that focuses on the individual case to understand behaviour • nomothetic approach to research that to study human behaviour through the development of general principles Idiographic • focus - uniqueness. We should be looking at people individually and not attempt to make comparisons to norms • types of experiment used - case studies, unstructured interviews, other self report methods Type of data collected - Qualitative to gain rich and insightful description of human experience subjective - individual and personal experience, motivation and values, hard to replicate Idiographic vs nomothetic approach 1 • Outcomes - understanding - not concerned with general laws or comparing with large groups • case studies - Clive wearing, Gage, Genie, little Hans approaches - Psychodynamic (different experiences of psychosexual stages), humanistic (hierarchy of needs - different experience of each level) ● Nomothetic • focus - generalisations- understanding behaviour on a wider scale and looking at large numbers of people to apply a behaviour to the population • Type of experiment used - scientific methods - where hypotheses can be formulated and tested under controlled conditions ● Type of data collected - quantitative - to gain more data and make easier comparisons across groups • Scientific - objective - employs scientific methods and obtains quantitative data - harder to make interpretations from • Outcomes - prediction - concerned with comparing...
68 Idiographic vs nomothetic approach ● Idiographic - approach to research that focuses on the individual case to understand behaviour • nomothetic approach to research that to study human behaviour through the development of general principles Idiographic • focus - uniqueness. We should be looking at people individually and not attempt to make comparisons to norms • types of experiment used - case studies, unstructured interviews, other self report methods Type of data collected - Qualitative to gain rich and insightful description of human experience subjective - individual and personal experience, motivation and values, hard to replicate Idiographic vs nomothetic approach 1 • Outcomes - understanding - not concerned with general laws or comparing with large groups • case studies - Clive wearing, Gage, Genie, little Hans approaches - Psychodynamic (different experiences of psychosexual stages), humanistic (hierarchy of needs - different experience of each level) ● Nomothetic • focus - generalisations- understanding behaviour on a wider scale and looking at large numbers of people to apply a behaviour to the population • Type of experiment used - scientific methods - where hypotheses can be formulated and tested under controlled conditions ● Type of data collected - quantitative - to gain more data and make easier comparisons across groups • Scientific - objective - employs scientific methods and obtains quantitative data - harder to make interpretations from • Outcomes - prediction - concerned with comparing...
iOS User
Stefan S, iOS User
SuSSan, iOS User
large groups and being able to make predictions about future behaviour to control it ● approaches - behaviourist (findings are applied to all and uses lab experiments), cognitive (cognitive neuroscience), biological (uses objective methods, GWAS), social learning theory (uses lab experiments) • key studies - Strange situation, Asch's line study, Milgram's obedience experiment, Adorno Hazan and Shaver idiographic approaches are more likely to give a complete account of behaviour because it uses qualitative methods to provide in depth and global descriptions of individual cases o Cannot generalise and make general laws without further research o means that we do not have complete theories for all human behaviour, only small cases Idiographic vs nomothetic approach 2 o Idiographic approaches can reveal important information about single cases to generate hypotheses about wider population behaviour and then nomothetic research can be conducted ▪ Example: Clive wearing as a case study - Tulving(1997) who did a brain scan to back up these findings on LTM o Nomothetic approaches have greater scientific credibility - makes studies more objective and replicable which increases validity o Nomothetic approaches look at big samples and generalisation which means we lose a person's experience Study ■ For example, we know that there is a 1% lifetime risk in the general population for developing schizophrenia - this doesn't tell us the subjective experience of what it is like to live with schizophrenia Koluchova - Twin boys were locked in a cupboard from 18m to 7y. After they were found they lived in a loving family and they recovered fully. This showed that there may not be a critical period for psychological damage and any damage can be overcome Using SSRIs to treat depression - these antidepressant drugs prevent the reabsorption and breakdown of serotonin so there is an increase in the level of serotonin at the synapse Idiographic vs nomothetic approach I or N? Idiographic Nomothetic Justification Because it is a case study and qualitative data is collected and the findings are used to draw the conclusion that there may not be a critical period which is applied to the greater population Uses lab experiments and brain scans to find this out 3 Study Gardner and Gardner - Attempted to teach a chimp to use sign language. Over 32 months detailed records were kept of the progress where 30 signs could be made in 2 way conversations. This showed that a chimpanzee does have the capability to use human language Eysenck's personality theory: personality can be broken down into two different dimensions: neuroticism-stability and introversion-extraversion. Everyone varies in the extent to which we are introvert or extravert or neurotic. These are measured by a personality questionnaire. Idiographic vs Nomothetic - evaluation Idiographic vs nomothetic approach I or N? Idiographic Nomothetic Justification collects qualitative data and only studies one chimp and findings are generalised Collects a range of data from different people 4