Agreements and Disagreements at the Convention
The delegates agreed on the weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation and the need for a stronger national government, but they disagreed on the structure. Three competing plans emerged with different visions.
The Virginia Plan, proposed by Edmund Randolph and James Madison, called for three branches of government and a bicameral legislature with representation based on state population. The lower house would be directly elected by voters while the upper house would be chosen by state legislatures.
The New Jersey Plan, offered by William Paterson, wanted to keep the Articles but add taxing power and trade regulation. It proposed a unicameral legislature with equal representation for all states, regardless of size.
Did you know? Alexander Hamilton's "Conservative Plan" was the most radical, proposing a president and Congress elected for life—reminiscent of the monarchy they had fought to escape!
The final Constitution incorporated elements from multiple plans: the three-branch structure from Virginia, equal Senate representation from New Jersey, and a somewhat stronger federal government from Hamilton's vision, though far less extreme than he wanted.