Kohlberg's 1958 Study
How would you solve a moral dilemma? Kohlberg presented research participants with the famous Heinz Dilemma: Should a man named Heinz steal an overpriced drug to save his dying wife?
In this scenario, a druggist discovered a drug that could save Heinz's dying wife but charged 2,000whenitonlycost200 to make. When Heinz could only raise $1,000 and the druggist refused to lower the price, Heinz broke into the laboratory to steal the medication.
What makes this study fascinating isn't whether people thought Heinz should steal the drug—it's their reasoning process behind the decision. Kohlberg noted that younger participants used simpler reasoning while older subjects considered more complex moral principles.
This study became the foundation for Kohlberg's Stages of Moral Development, showing how our moral thinking evolves as we mature.
Critical Thinking: When considering this dilemma yourself, what factors influence your decision? Is it laws, relationships, principles of justice, or something else?